01The scenario
A runaway trolley will kill five people. You can pull a lever to divert it, killing one person on the other track. Do you pull it?
If the only way were to push a person off a bridge, would your answer change?
02What it asks
It contrasts consequentialism (judge by outcomes; saving five is better) with deontology (do not intentionally kill an innocent person).
Most people pull the lever in the first case and hesitate in the second, showing that judgement is not purely outcome-based.
03What it means for you
Real choices are rarely this extreme, but the tension exists: may a minority’s rights be sacrificed for a greater good?
The experiment gives no answer; it gives an honest audit of your moral intuitions.
Sources & notes
Original editorial writing; philosophical references follow standard editions.
This article combines philosophical interpretation with established psychological concepts. It is educational content, not diagnosis or treatment. See our Disclaimer.